Skip to main content

Regular Shingles vs. Architectural Shingles 

Brian Elder Roofing

If you are looking to replace your roof, you have probably noticed there are many new roofing style options. The choices for roofing materials include asphalt, metal, designer architectural shingles, and more. There is a gamut of styles for your new roof. Sometimes your climate might dictate what shingles you choose, but usually, you have a choice between asphalt shingles and architectural shingles. Most homeowners choose to stick with what they know as asphalt shingles. Have you noticed that even asphalt shingles now have more asphalt shingle options than ever before on the market today? To help you choose between regular asphalt and architectural shingles here is some information on both that should help you with your choice. 

Benefits of Regular Asphalt Shingles 

Asphalt Shingles have three tabs. The bottom layer is made up of either felt or fiberglass. This layer protects your home from water infiltrating through your roof and supports the other two layers on the shingle. The next layer is the actual asphalt-asphalt comprised of many little granules that help shield UV rays. The asphalt is topped off with a surfacing material that allows this layer to keep its shape. The final tab contains adhesive or the seal strip. It secures the shingles into a single unit and helps protect your roof from the wind. Most asphalt shingles are three tabs, but you could opt for a 4-tab style. The 4-tab type will add an additional layer of protection. Some of the benefits of asphalt shingles include: 

  • They are durable 
  • They are energy efficient 
  • They are cost-efficient 
  • Installation is easy and quick 
  • You can choose between many colors 
  • Repairs are simple  

Benefits of Architectural Shingles 

Asphalt and architectural shingles are similar in that their underpinnings are precisely the same, but the styles differ in how they are layered. Architectural shingles aimed to mimic slate or wood shake roofing. So rather than lying flat, the shingles are made up of two layers laminated together to create a contoured appearance. While many people love the look of architectural shingles, the aesthetic appeal isn’t the only reason more people are starting to opt for this style. The type of layering increases durability and wind resistance which is reflected in more extended warranties. The benefits include: 

  • Higher resistance to wind 
  • Increases curb appeal 
  • Better durability 

Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles vs. Architectural Shingles 

Are architectural shingles worth the extra cost? Some people believe that even though architectural shingles are more expensive, a more extended warranty and better durability offset the price. So, deciding if architectural shingles are worth it depends on your budget and style choice. 

When choosing based on style, how do the other homes in your neighborhood look? Would you like your home to blend in with the other homes keeping a cohesive look to the neighborhood? If your home is unique and each home is different in the neighborhood, you might think that an architectural style would look the best on your home. 

Regarding performance, consider your geography. Do you live somewhere that is particularly windy and often experiences extreme weather, or do you have more mild weather? If you have mild weather, traditional asphalt shingles offer excellent durability at a better price. Yet, if you’re in an area with extreme weather, it makes sense to go with architectural shingles. 

Roofing Repair and Replacement Near Me 

If you are in the mid-south area, the #1 roofer in town is Brian Elder Roofing. We are licensed, insured, and bonded, and we offer over a decade of roofing experience. We use only the best roofing materials on the market, and our roofers are knowledgeable, quick, and conscientious. Whether you need an entire roof replaced or regular roof maintenance, we have you covered. Contact us today at (901) 867-0303.